Updated date:

Review of "Thy Kingdom Gone" by German Gothic Metal Band Flowing Tears

Ara is a Journalism graduate from California State University Northridge who is always looking to explore his writing opportunities.

A Little Bit About the Band Flowing Tears and How They Looked Like In 2008

German Gothic metal and rock band Flowing Tears took a while to release a new album. That album is called Thy Kingdom Gone released in 2008. For this album we have a new bassist. His name is David Vogt (originally David Kiefer). David is married to vocalist Helen Vogt. That is the only lineup change for this album. As great as 2004’s Razorbliss was, already I am very impressed with this album even though I had not listened to the album in its entirety when I first began reviewing the album. This album is more melodic than the mentioned 2004 album.

How is Thy Kingdom Gone Different From Razorbliss?

One example of this is the song called Miss Fortune. There is much piano playing and I sense a part in the guitar work that the band called The Gathering would incorporate into their songs. Colossal Shaped Despair is about the impending decline of the world as faith in humanity is lost. It can be very hard to have faith in humanity when there are so many humans that take advantage of others, lie, cheat, or steal to achieve their objectives. But sometimes faith is what has the power to turn a person’s life around. After some deep chanting vocals by Helen, the song slows down and ends. Kismet features a softer side to the voice of Helen Vogt. Variety especially in the case of this band helps because then listeners will see that this is not a generic Gothic rock band. Kismet also has some Paradise Lost influenced guitar playing in it. For My Enemies is a different kind of song because Helen sounds like she is whispering and she even lets out a death metal growl in this song.

The Song Called Grey

Thy Kingdom Gone Is Different From Razorbliss But It Is Still Good

Thy Kingdom Gone may be different in style compared to Razorbliss but it does not match that album in terms of greatness. The vocal power of Helen that we heard on the song Razorbliss does exist on this album but the greatness of that title track cannot be underestimated. Also, Thy Kingdom Gone does not have as good or catchy songs as Snakes of Grey or Undying. Razorbliss was the band’s peak but this one is pretty darn good as well.

Flowing Tears Discography

I wrote this list in honor of Flowing Tears having ended their career.

Year ReleasedAlbum Title 










Thy Kingdom Gone



How Is the Beginning of the Album?

Orchidfire has piano parts similar to what Amorphis used in the first song of the Tales from the Thousand Lakes album. The song speeds up to provide some contrast. Pain Has Taken Over reminds me a little bit of what Lullacry would do in their earlier albums as they used melody that was similar. We hear a melodic guitar interlude in this song, something that was not really present in their previous album. Rain of a Thousand Years is about a relationship that ended and there is no return for the couples because they are lacking something, more like a good “night” to turn things around in the right direction. Because as the song says “only the night can save, we were lost before the start.” Grey is the first song that I heard from this album and the power of Helen’s voice caught my attention within a short time. It seems four years really made a difference as she probably worked on her voice to put some power into it.

Final Thoughts on the Album Thy Kingdom Gone

After a first full listen of Thy Kingdom Gone, this writer says that the album is a solid work but still falls short of matching Razorbliss. Even so, it is one of Flowing Tears’ better albums. This would be the last album for this German band because they would break up in 2013 after almost two decades together as a band. Lullacry would soon follow breaking up in 2014. Helen Vogt is still young at 34 and I hope that she returns to the music business later on because she has talent that she should use. If the album were to get a final score, we would probably give it an 85 out of 100 points.


© 2016 Ara Vahanian

Related Articles