Skip to main content

Mötley Crüe Albums Ranked First to Worst

The author is a guitarist and bassist with over 35 years of experience as a musician.

Mötley Crüe bassist Nikki Sixx (left) and guitarist Mick Mars

Mötley Crüe bassist Nikki Sixx (left) and guitarist Mick Mars

Who Is Mötley Crüe?

While their lineup has varied at different points in the band’s history, the four principle members of Mötley Crüe are:

  • Vince Neil: Vocals
  • Mick Mars: Guitar
  • Nikki Sixx: Bass
  • Tommy Lee: Drums

Golden Age of Glam-Metal: Early '80s–Early '90s

I don’t consider myself an especially lucky person, but with music, I often realize how fortunate I am to have lived through one of the most amazing periods in rock history. The glam-metal era spanned from the early 1980s to the early 1990s. It was a time of larger-than-life bands, amazing music, and a lot of fun.

There were a few key players that helped make it all happen. Van Halen was the prototype band in the late ‘70s. Quiet Riot paved the way on mainstream radio. But, for the attitude and style most of us associate with glam metal, no band had more of an impact than Motley Crue. While they didn’t invent the glam image, they took it to another level.

Mötley Crüe Reinvented Glam in the '80s

Mötley Crüe tore through the ‘80s with a string of successful albums and hit songs. Record companies scrambled to sign any group that looked and sounded like them. Dozens of bands that had honed their chops on the Sunset Strip became rock stars overnight. Young musicians flocked to Los Angeles from around the world, hoping to get in on the action. Aqua Net was in high demand.

By the early ‘90s, it was all over, and all that remained was the post-party cleanup. While glam gets a lot of criticism in modern times, those days featured some of the most exciting bands in this history of rock, and some of the best musicians.

This article highlights the top albums and songs by Motley Crue. If you are too young to have experienced the glam era first-hand and want to know what it was all about, this is a great place to start.

Read on to learn more about the best songs on each album. Be sure to vote for your favorite Crue record in the poll at the bottom of this article!

Mötley Crüe Albums Ranked

  1. Too Fast for Love (1981, 1982)
  2. Shout at the Devil (1983)
  3. Dr. Feelgood (1989)
  4. Theatre of Pain (1985)
  5. Girls, Girls, Girls (1987)
  6. Saints of Los Angeles (2008)
  7. New Tattoo (2000)
  8. Generation Swine (1997)
  9. Mötley Crüe (1994)

1. Too Fast for Love (1981, 1982)

I realize my first pick might be a little controversial, as Mötley Crüe went on to record many multi-platinum albums during the ‘80s. While their debut record eventually reached platinum status, it was almost certainly due to the success of the albums that followed.

Still, if I could only have one Crüe album, Too Fast for Love would be the one. It was their first album in 1981, though it would be remixed and re-released by Elektra in 1982. If you want to know what the Crüe was all about this is where you start.

Like most rock bands, Mötley Crüe’s sound became more polished as their popularity rose. In contrast, Too Fast for Love has the gritty desperation of four guys willing to do anything to make it. Sixx’s songwriting is hard-hitting and raw, and Mars’s guitar tone has a nastiness to it that wouldn’t be surpassed until Dr. Feelgood many years later.

Best Songs from Too Fast for Love

  • "Take Me to the Top"
  • "Merry Go Round"
  • "Too Fast for Love"
  • "Live Wire"
  • "On With the Show"

2. Shout at the Devil (1983)

When Shout at the Devil hit record stores back in 1983, heavy music was starting to get mainstream attention. Quiet Riot’s Metal Health made it to number one on the Billboard 200 that year, giving metal a kind of acceptance it had never experienced. Def Leppard’s Pyromania made it as high as number two.

While Shout at the Devil only made it to number 17, it brought the band to the attention of new fans across the world. Still, this was a darker album, and the band's usage of satanic imagery as well as song titles like Shout at the Devil and God Bless the Children of the Beast probably hurt their chances more than helped.

Unless you were a young 12-year-old metal fan and guitarist from halfway across the country like me. In that case, you thought Mötley Crüe was the greatest thing you had ever seen. From the creepy spoken-word In the Beginning that kicks off the album and onward, this album reeks of attitude.

Top Songs from Shout at the Devil

  • "Shout at the Devil"
  • "Looks That Kill"
  • "Too Young to Fall in Love"
  • "Ten Seconds to Love"
  • "Knock ‘Em Dead Kid"

3. Dr. Feelgood (1989)

Where Shout at the Devil marked their ascent in the early ‘80s, Dr. Feelgood closed out the decade on a strong note in 1989. By this point, the band had achieved astronomical success with three multi-platinum albums and a string of chart-topping singles. Mötley Crüe started the ‘80s as a band for metalheads, but by the end of the ‘decade, they were a band for everyone.

But so went the trend of glam metal. These were the glory days, and they were reaping the rewards, with Dr. Feelgood eventually grabbing the top spot on the Billboard 200.

However, I’ll admit they had lost me a little bit. I remained a fan through the decade, but the two records that followed Shout at the Devil had drifted away from the sound and attitude I loved on their first two albums.

They swung the ship around with Dr. Feelgood. Mars’s guitar tone is crushing on this album, probably the best of his career. In my opinion, he is one of the most underrated guitarists of the glam era. While not as edgy as their first two albums, the songwriting brings back a little bit of that grit.

Essential Songs on Dr. Feelgood

  • "Dr. Feelgood"
  • "Kickstart My Heart"
  • "Same Ol’ Situation"
  • "Don’t Go Away Mad"
  • "Without You"

4. Theatre of Pain (1985)

Theatre of Pain (1985) marked a significant turning point for Motley Crue, and glam metal in general. This is the record that catapulted the band into the stratosphere, and altered the rules of metal.

On this album, the band began to drift to a more blues-based sound with "Smokin’ in the Boys’ Room" (a Brownsville Station cover).

The other change was the introduction of the radio-friendly power ballad, specifically the song "Home Sweet Home."

Power ballads were nothing new to hard rock, but this was a band that had been singing about the devil a couple of years earlier, and now had the attention of half the high-school girls in the country.

And it was a sudden shift. For two years, the girls in my class thought I was weird for wearing Motley Crue buttons on my jacket. Then "Home Sweet Home" came out, and they were asking where they could get them. (Answer: from the ads in Circus Magazine.)

"Home Sweet Home" was huge, and from then on, every hard rock and glam metal band made it a point to include a power ballad on every record. "Every Rose Has Its Thorn." "Heaven." "I Remember You." For better or worse, thank "Home Sweet Home" for all of them.

Best Songs from Theatre of Pain

  • "Smokin' in the Boys' Room"
  • "Home Sweet Home"
  • "Louder Than Hell"
  • "Save Our Souls"
  • "Raise Your Hands to Rock"

5. Girls, Girls, Girls (1987)

The Crüe’s fourth studio album hit the shelves in 1987. The opening song, "Wild Side," is a great track, and the title track got a lot of attention. But following the success of "Smokin’ in the Boys’ Room," the band leaned ever further toward a bluesy, decidedly less-metal sound. Thanks to this more-palatable-for-the-mainstream sound, Girls, Girls, Girls reached number two on the Billboard 200.

Guitarist Mick Mars is nearly a decade older than the other members of the band. He spent his twenties playing in blues-rock bands while the rest of the guys were in high school (or supposed to be). So, it’s easy to see how he may be calling back on his early influences with many of the riffs on this record.

If that kind of bluesy hard rock appeals to you, you might love Girls, Girls, Girls. As for me, at the time, I felt it was a decent album with a couple of good songs and a bunch of filler.

Top Songs from Girls, Girls, Girls

  • "Girls, Girls, Girls"
  • "Wild Side"
  • "You’re All I Need"
  • "All in the Name Of..."
  • "Sumthin’ for Nothin’"

6. Saints of Los Angeles (2008)

Saints of Los Angeles came out in 2008, twenty-seven years after Motley Crue released their first album. I think it is important to consider everything that had happened in heavy music during that period.

Glam came and went. Grunge came and went. Thrash and death metal came out of the underground, then went back again. Nu-metal popped up for a brief period before thankfully fading into obscurity.

Mötley Crüe themselves went through massive changes. Vince Neil left and returned. Tommy Lee left and returned. Their last few albums were subpar, to put it kindly.

Then came 2008 and Saints of Los Angeles. This was their last studio album, and to me, it is the perfect end to the band’s career. It’s edgy. It’s hard rock. It’s the gutsy sound and attitude that grabbed me back in the early ‘80s.

Essential Songs from Saints of Los Angeles

  • "Saints of Los Angeles"
  • "Down at the Whiskey"
  • "Face Down in the Dirt"

7. New Tattoo (2000)

New Tattoo came out in 2000, following one of their weakest albums of all time, Generation Swine. Commercially, New Tattoo fared much worse. However, it was a return to the sound and songwriting tropes that carried the band through the ‘80s.

"Hell on High Heels" is a great track that could have stood out on any Crüe record back in the ‘80s. Unfortunately, that’s about the best I can say about this record. It’s not a bad album. It’s just unremarkable.

A Noteworthy Song from New Tattoo

  • "Hell on High Heels"

8. Generation Swine (1997)

It’s easy to look back at Generation Swine from 1997 and throw barbs, but I think it is important to consider it in context with everything else that was going on back then in the music world. Only a few years earlier, the glam metal genre had been chugging along. Then came grunge, and suddenly many of the most influential groups from the previous decade were not only pushed aside, but they were also outright ridiculed.

So, what did the top glam metal band in the world do when the gravy train suddenly came to a screeching halt? Well, first, they fell apart. Vince Neil went off on a solo career, and the remaining members recorded a sub-par record with a new singer.

When management convinced the band to reunite, it was cause for celebration for fans, until the record came out. I recall being sorely disappointed in Generation Swine. The sound was so different, and it was easy to accuse them of selling out and trying to fit in with a changing music landscape.

Again, looking back with the wisdom of hindsight, what were they supposed to do? They weren’t the only metal juggernauts whose sound took a major left turn during that time (Metallica, I’m looking at you). Plus, bands like Aerosmith, Heart, and KISS had changed their sound to better fit in with the ‘80s rock scene. You do what you gotta do to survive, I guess.

Best Songs from Generation Swine

  • "Afraid"
  • "Beauty"

9. Mötley Crüe (1994)

Vocalist Vince Neil left the band in 1992 after clashes with the other members. Neil went off to pursue a solo career, and the group brought in John Corabi to take his place.

Like Generation Swine, the sound on the self-titled Mötley Crüe (1994) is very un-Crüe. Corabi shares songwriting credits with Sixx on all songs, so it is understandable how a new influence would change the sound. Still, it wasn’t what most fans were expecting.

The album isn’t great, but it also isn’t fair to level too much criticism at the founding members of the group, or even at Corabi. It’s tough to find the right chemistry to make a band successful, and expecting a new frontman to step in and have the same impact as Vince Neil is probably not realistic.

Top Songs from Mötley Crüe

  • "Hooligan's Holiday"
  • "Hammered"

Mötley Crüe Studio Albums

AlbumYearTop Single

Too Fast for Love

1981, 1982

"Live Wire"

Shout at the Devil

1983

"Shout at the Devil"

Theatre of Pain

1985

"Smokin' in the Boys' Room"

Girls, Girls, Girls

1987

"Girls, Girls, Girls"

Dr. Feelgood

1989

"Dr. Feelgood"

Mötley Crüe

1994

"Hooligan's Holiday"

Generation Swine

1997

"Afraid"

New Tattoo

2000

"Hell on High Heels"

Saints of Los Angeles

2008

"Saints of Los Angeles"

A Decade of Decadence

Rock music was different during Mötley Crüe’s reign. It was all about having fun, and the bands were over-the-top and wild. When grunge came along, things changed. Music became depressing, and the guys in the bands looked like people you’d see on the street.

I don’t want rock stars that look like ordinary people. I want rock stars that look, dress, and act in ways that aren’t appropriate in real life. I want to see them driving sports cars and riding Harleys with supermodels on the back. Maybe they get arrested now and then, though hopefully not for anything too serious.

When I go to a concert, I want to see four guys who look like they love what they’re doing, not four guys standing there looking depressed. I want to see a drum solo performed by an upside-down spinning maniac. I want to see fire and explosions and thousands of people having a great time.

Mötley Crüe released some great music, but just as importantly, they set the bar for the most exciting decade rock music has ever seen. Many amazing bands followed on their heels, and while they were all a lot of fun, none of them quite matched the Crüe.

So, if you lived through the ‘80s as I did, consider yourself lucky to have experienced it all. If not, now is the time to get acquainted with some great music.

Which Is the Best Mötley Crüe Album?

This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.