CJ Baker is a published writer who recently started the podcast "Ongoing History of Protest Music."
Rock & Roll Hall of Controversy
Every time the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame announces new inductees and has a new ceremony, it always opens up new debates. One of the biggest causes of debate is the names that have gotten snubbed. The reality is, even if Hall goes through radical reforms concerning their process, these questions are always going to remain.
To begin with, the list of deserving artists who have NOT been inducted is so considerable there is no way you are going to get around to include everyone. The other aspect is that the process is just so subjective. What makes one musical artist more worthy of inclusion than another? But it is those debates that make the process so much fun.
So I decided to throw my hat into the debate. When I was going through the list of names that are eligible but have never been inducted, I ended up with a long list of 75 artists that I felt deserved serious consideration for induction. So after much scrutiny, I narrowed it down to 15. I tried being as objective as possible. So I included artists that I am generally not into, while I excluded some personal favorites.
What were the main criteria? Some feel that it should be commercial success. I personally disagree with that contention. Even though that can be taken into consideration, overall musical influence should be the primary determining factor. To me, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame should be a museum that outlines the evolution and historical developments of rock music. All genres that have affected the landscape of modern rock music (yes, that includes rap/hip hop) need to be represented to tell the whole story. If commercial success were the only determining factor, there would be some huge gaps in the evolutionary chain.
So here is my list of 15 artists who deserve to be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Just as a note, this article was originally written in 2012. Periodically new names are added to the list, to replace those that eventually get inducted. Just as a note, looking back there are a few artists that I would now consider snubs, and if I were to completely revamp the list it would probably be a bit different. But I'm only replacing an artist to replace someone newly inducted. Please feel free to let me know whom you feel has been unjustly excluded from the Hall (and my list) in the comments.
#15: Big Star
Years Snubbed: 24 Years Nominated: 0
Big Star never sold well commercially, but they are widely considered to be the most influential cult band other than The Velvet Underground (who were inducted in 1996). Their extent of influence on power pop and "indie rock" is immeasurable. Teenage Fanclub, The Replacements (who recorded the song "Alex Chilton" as a tribute), The Lemonheads, Wilco, The Afghan Whig among many others have cited the band as an influence. Also, R.E.M.'s (inducted in 2007) Peter Buck made the following statement concerning Big Star's influence on them: "We've sort of flirted with greatness, but we've yet to make a record as good as Revolver or Highway 61 Revisited or Exile on Main Street or Big Star's Third."
Thirteen - Big Star
Pixies Performing In 2004
Years Snubbed: 10 Years Nominated: 0
Even though they haven't been eligible as long as other bands on this list, their influence is undeniable. They helped create the loud-soft dynamic which became the trademark of the grunge sound. They were one of the bands which helped paved the way for the alt-rock explosion of the early 90s.
Also when Kurt Cobain wrote "Smells Like Teen Spirit" he acknowledged that he was trying to write a Pixies song. For that legacy alone the band deserves considerable consideration. It would have also been really cool if they were inducted into the 2014 class along with Nirvana. As much as Nirvana deserves to be inducted in their first year of eligibility, there are some definite evolutionary gaps in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Inducting bands such as the Pixies will provide context on the historical development of Nirvana and alternative rock.
The Pixies sold relatively modest in North America during their initial run (1987-93), but they sold well in the UK and parts of Europe. Their profile also increased over time and when they reunited in 2004 they embarked on a sold-out tour and became a popular festival draw.
Also even though they failed to make my list of 15, it is a positive sign that The Replacements were nominated for the 2014 class. This is a sign that the Rock & Roll Hall Fame is closer to recognizing some of the underground bands that helped influence the development of alternative rock.
Read More From Spinditty
Pixies - Where Is My Mind
Years Snubbed: 29 Years Nominated: 2003, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2022
With their rebellious spirit, musical attack, and left-wing radical political ideology they are one of the bands that served as an important precursor to the development of the punk scene. The bands' 1969 trademark song, "Kick Out The Jams" was considered controversial for dropping the f-bomb (which was still considered shocking back then). The fact that the song even cracked the Hot 100 charts (#82) is pretty phenomenal. It is also a major snub that "Kick Out The Jams" is not listed in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame as one of the songs "That Shaped Rock & Roll."
Two of the band's albums were included in Rolling Stone's list of "The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time", Kick Out The Jams (#294) and Back In The USA (#451). They were considered to be an influence on The Stooges (inducted in 2010) who were contemporaries of the same scene. MC5 is considered an influence not only on a number of punk acts but on a number of politically charged rock acts such as Rage Against The Machine (who covered their Kick Out The Jams, which has become an oft-covered modern rock standard). The band also established a reputation for their high-energy live shows which are considered truly legendary.
MC5 - Remastered Tartar Field - Ramblin Rose/Kick Out The Jams/Looking At You - July 1970
1986 Photo of Kate Bush
#12: Kate Bush
Years Snubbed: 18 Years Nominated: 2018, 2021, 2022
Kate Bush did not have a huge commercial presence in the States where she only had one top 40 hit, "Running Up That Hill (A Deal with God)" (but she did manage 5 hits on the US Modern Rock chart). But she was hugely successful in her native UK (she also sold well in my native country Canada) where she had 7 platinum albums and 25 Top 40 hits. But her influence extends well beyond commercial success.
Since the 80s the media would inevitably compare any unique female singer-songwriter to Kate Bush. Tori Amos, Björk (cited Kate's 1982 album, The Dreaming as one of her favorites), PJ Harvey, Florence Welch (of Florence and The Machine) have all cited her as an influence. Influential Trip-Hop pioneer Tricky made the following statement concerning her influence: "I don't believe in God, but if I did, her music would be my bible". John Lydon (Rotten) of the Sex Pistols (inducted in 2006) described her music as "beauty beyond belief" and called her "a true original". Also, Chris Martin of Coldplay acknowledged that when they wrote "Speed of Sound" they were patterning it after "Running Up That Hill (A Deal with God)". Along with her music, Kate is also considered influential for her artistic and cinematic music videos.
Cloudbusting - Kate Bush
#11: Gram Parsons
Years Snubbed: 29 Years Nominated: 2002, 2004, 2005
Gram Parsons got his start in 1968 with the International Submarine Band. He had a stint with The Byrds (but was not included as part of the band when they were inducted in the Hall back in 1991), where he was a major contributor to their 1968 album, Sweethearts of The Rodeo. That album was considered a commercial disappointment at the time, but the album is now considered to be highly influential in the development of "country rock." The song "Hickory Wind" (which Parsons co-wrote) is in the Hall as one of the songs "That Shaped Rock & Roll". From there he recorded two highly influential albums with The Flying Burrito Brothers Their song "Sin City" (which Parsons co-wrote) is included in the Hall as one of the songs "That Shaped Rock & Roll". As a solo artist, he released two studio albums, which may not have fared well commercially, but are considered highly influential.
Gram Parsons helped introduced Emmylou Harris (who continues to champion his work). Mick Jagger of The Rolling Stones (inducted in 1989) said the following concerning Parsons' influence on him: "He was one of the few people who helped me sing country music. Before that, Keith and I would just copy off records." He is also extremely influential in the modern-day development of what is known as "alt-country" influencing bands such as Cowboy Junkies, The Jayhawks & Wilco.
Gram Parsons & Emmylou Harris
#10: Son House
Years Snubbed: 36 Years Nominated:0
Because Son House's first recordings predate the formation of Rock & Roll he would most likely be considered an early influence (which goes through a different voting process). Son House's influence on the Blues (which of course is an important part of rock's DNA) is simply phenomenal. Son House is widely considered as the individual who helped Robert Johnson (who was inducted as an early influence back in 1986) and he was considered a major influence on Muddy Waters (who was inducted in 1987). Those factors alone made him worthy of consideration during the infancy of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame (which was inaugurated back in 1986).
It is also good to note that Son House continues to exert an indelible imprint on modern rock. A prime example is the influence that Son House had on Jack White. The White Stripes dedicated their 1999 self-titled debut album to the memory of Son House. They have recorded Son House's "Death Letter" and have also incorporated elements from "John The Revelator" (which is a traditional tune, but the band cited House's version as the influence) into their song "Cannon". Also during the documentary "It Might Get Loud" Jack White cited Son House's "Grinnin' in Your Face" as his favorite song and a major influence on him.
House is just one example of an influential blues & roots music artist that has been neglected entry into the Hall. I could easily compile a list of 15 early influences (the hard part would be to narrow it down to 15) that deserve induction into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. It would be nice if every year they would induct 2-3 early influences (it would be good to use it as more than just a back door category for nominated performers who don't get in). This will help to fill the many gaps in the Hall.
Son House's "Grinnin' in Your Face" is Jack White's Favorite Song
Years Snubbed: 19 Years Nominated: 2020
Motörhead's hybrid of punk & metal was an important precursor to the New Wave of British Heavy Metal, and they were extremely influential in the development of "speed metal" and "thrash metal". Even though I don't argue with Metallica's inclusion (inducted 2009) it is shame that a pioneering band that helped influenced them and their genre was neglected. Also, former Guns N' Roses (inducted 2012) guitarist Slash got his start in a Motörhead cover band while in his teens.
The band has managed to sell over 30 million worldwide, and 15 million albums in the US, which is pretty good for a non-commercial band that never received a whole lot of radio play. I also feel it was a slight not to include "Ace of Spades" in the Hall of Fame as one of the "Songs That Shaped Rock & Roll."
That being said if they ever were inducted, it would have been interesting whether or not they would have shown up to the ceremony or pulled a Sex Pistols. Lemmy when asked about the many fan-driven petition campaigns to get Motörhead inducted into the Hall of Fame and whether or not he cares about being inducted made the following statement: "Not at all. Have you been there? What a monumental waste of space. The biggest room there is the freaking gift shop. Do you know what I mean? It's all politics that place. All a load of f---king politics."
Unfortunately, with the death of Phil (Philthy Animal) Taylor (November 21 September 1954 – 11 November 2015) and Ian "Lemmy" Kilmister (24 December 1945 – 28 December 2015) the question of them showing up becomes mute.
#8: Big Mama Thornton
Years Snubbed: 36 Years Nominated: 0
Thronton is another artist who would most likely be considered in the early influence category. She is criminally overlooked for her considerable role as a foremother of rock & roll.
She has the notable distinction of recording the first version of "Hound Dog." Her version was far grittier than the more well-known Elvis Presley (inducted in 1986) version. Even though her version did hit #1 on the R&B charts, the segregation of that period prevented it from being a hot 100 pop hit. Her rendition of "Hound Dog" is listed as one of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame's "500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll", and was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in February 2013.
Another one of her notable tunes is "Ball and Chain," a tune that she also composed. The song received wider attention when it was recorded by Janis Joplin (inducted in 1995). Joplin cited Thronton has a definitive influence on her. Thronton's version of "Ball and Chain" is also included on the list of "500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll".
Rock Island Line - Lonnie Donegan
#7: Lonnie Donegan
Years Snubbed: 36 Years Nominated: 0
If ever inducted will likely be inducted in the early influence category. Referred to as the "King of Skiffle", he had considerable influence on a slew of 60s British pop and rock influence. For example, inspired by Donegan, Paul McCartney (inducted 1999) and John Lennon (inducted 1994) were inspired to form a skiffle group The Quarrymen, which was a precursor to The Beatles (inducted 1988). McCartney made the following statement about Donegan: "He was the first person we had heard of from Britain to get to the coveted No. 1 in the charts, and we studied his records avidly. We all bought guitars to be in a skiffle group. He was the man."
Roger Daltrey of The Who (inducted in 1990), also commented on his influence: "I wanted to be Elvis Presley when I grew up, I knew that. But the man who really made me feel like I could actually go out and do it was a chap by the name of Lonnie Donegan."
Jack White summed it up best during an acceptance speech at the Brit Awards: "Remember, Lonnie Donegan, started it for you."
#6: Dick Dale
Years Snubbed: 35 Years Nominated: 0
Dick Dale is commonly referred to as the "King of the Surf Guitar" and he did help develop a new genre of music. His 1961 recording "Let's Go Trippin'" (which is in the Hall as one of the "Songs That Shaped Rock & Roll") is widely considered the first recorded surf rock instrumental. Shortly after that, bands influenced by Dale, like The Beach Boys (inducted in 1988), would add vocals to the surf rock sound. Along with helping to pioneer the "surf" sound, he came up with several other innovations that made him one of the most influential guitarists in the history of rock.
His rapid-fire single-note staccato picking technique was considered revolutionary and it influenced Heavy Metal and Hard Rock guitarists such as Eddie Van Halen (Van Halen inducted in 2007). Also, Jimi Hendrix (inducted in 1992) considered his flashy showmanship to be a major influence on him.
One of his biggest impacts on music was that he helped Leo Fender develop amplifiers that could handle increased volumes. The speaker blowing loudness and breakneck speed of his playing lead him to be declared by Guitar Player magazine as "The Father of Heavy Metal".
Dick Dale & The Del Tones - Misirlou
#5: "Weird Al" Yankovic
Years Snubbed: 17 Years Nominated: 0
It is tough to gauge Yankovic's influence in musical terms because it is not like there as been numerous rock parodists inspired by "Weird Al" to go on and transform the music industry. But "Weird Al" deserves consideration because he occupies a unique position in the Rock & Roll landscape. He is also a pop culture phenom.
When "Weird Al" started his musical career three decades ago no one anticipated that he would be more than a novelty artist with a short lifespan. He defied all odds by carving out a profitable musical niche for himself. His longevity and commercial success even exceed a number of the artists that he has parodied. Part of the reason he continues to be relevant is because of his ability to adapt to changing genres.
Also, he is generally well respected within the music community and many music artists view it as a badge of honor to be parodied by "Weird Al". For example, David Grohl when he was drumming for Nirvana said that the band felt like they had "made it" when "Weird Al" parodied "Smells Like Teen Spirit". Kurt Cobain described him as "a musical genius".
"Weird Al" is not only the foremost Rock & Roll parodist, but he adds some much-needed humor to a music scene that often takes itself too seriously. During a 2009 Rolling Stone Reader Poll, Weird Al finished 1st on a list of who should be inducted to the Rock & Roll Roll Hall of Fame (followed by Rush (who was finally inducted into the 2013 class), Moody Blues (inducted in 2018) & The Smiths).
Homer Simpson summed it up best: "He who is tired of Weird Al is tired of life."
Smells Like Nirvana - "Weird Al" Yankovic
#4: Link Wray
Years Snubbed: 36 Years Nominated: 2014, 2018
Just like Dick Dale, Link Wray is one of the most influential guitarists in the history of rock & roll. Also, like Dale, he has been erroneously overlooked for inclusion into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Wray has been eligible for induction since Hall's inception in 1986. He should have been seriously considered way back then.
He is credited with inventing the power chord. His sound could be considered the blueprint for heavy metal and he served as an important precursor to punk. In connection with this, Rolling Stone magazine named him #67 as the greatest guitarist of all time. In the documentary "It Might Get Loud", Jimmy Page talked about how Link Wray's "Rumble" (which is in the Hall as one of the "Songs That Shaped Rock & Roll" and in 2009 was listed by The Library of Congress as part of the National Recording Registry honoring culturally significant recordings) was a major influence on him.
Here are some quotes concerning Link Wray's influence:
"If I could go back in time and see one concert it would be Link Wray and His Raymen" - Neil Young (inducted in 1995)
"He is the King; if it hadn't been for Rumble, I would have never picked up a guitar." -- Pete Townsend (The Who inducted in 1990)
He is inducted into the Rockabilly Hall of Fame, so hopefully, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame will follow suit. As a positive sign, he was finally nominated in 2014 and again in 2018. Also in 2018, "Rumble" was inducted into the Hall in the newly instituted Singles category. All six of the singles were from artists not currently inducted.
Jimmy Page Listening To Rumble
#3: The Smiths
Years Snubbed: 14 Years Nominated: 2015, 2016
Except for the Pixies, The Smiths haven't been waiting as long as the other artists on this list. The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame also has a long history of ignoring UK artists that didn't sell well (or as well) in the States. That being said, it is a positive sign that the band was nominated for both the 2015 and 2016 classes.
The Smiths are quite simply one of the most important indies and alternative bands ever (the band coming up next on this list may arguably exceed them). Right off the bat, just about every UK alternative band (commonly referred to as brit-pop) cites The Smiths as an influence, along with many US indie and alternative artists. This would include bands such as James, The Stone Roses, Suede, Blur, The Libertines, Beck, Modest Mouse, Death Cab for Cutie. Noel Gallagher of Oasis made the following statement about The Smiths' considerable influence: "When The Jam split, The Smiths started, and I totally went for them." Since the Gallagher brothers don't like anyone that is an impressive statement.
Morrissey's real-life (and sometimes dark) narrative blended with Johnny Marr's jangly guitar didn't sound like anything else that came from the 80s (even though they spawned several UK sound-alikes). It is good to note that they achieved their UK success on an indie label, on their own terms.
As the years go by the band continues to increase in status. For example, Morrissey reported that in 2006 the band was offered 5 million dollars to reunite to perform at the Coachella Music Festival. Their albums also sold better in the States as back cataloged than what they did when they were together (two of their studio albums and one of their compilations went Gold after their breakup).
How Soon is Now? - The Smiths
Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth
#2: Sonic Youth
Years Snubbed: 15 Years Nominated: 0
Except for The Smiths and Pixies, they haven't been waiting as long as other bands on this list. But they are arguably the most important indie and underground rock band ever. With Nirvana being inducted in 2014 (their first year of eligibility), it is a shame that a band like Sonic Youth that directly influenced them is not inducted first. It would have also been cool if they were inducted at the same time as Nirvana.
As an independent band, Sonic Youth released three albums: EVOL, Sister, and Daydream Nation that were considered important blueprints for the development of indie and alternative rock (including sub-genres such as grunge). Concerning Daydream Nation, in 2006 that album was listed in the Library of Congress National Recording Registry acknowledging musical recordings of cultural importance. The song "Teenage Riot" from that album is included in the Hall as one of the songs that "Shaped Rock & Roll".
One of the band's most significant developments was when they signed to Geffen Records. Despite being signed to a major label the band had a contract that allowed them to maintain complete creative control. This was one of the main factors of Nirvana deciding to sign to Geffen (Sonic Youth was one of Kurt Cobain's idols). From there the flood gates opened and this led to the alternative rock explosion of the 90s.
The band continued to maintain a large cult following and bassist Kim Gordon proved to be an influential component of the Riot Grrrl movement inspiring bands such as L7, Hole, Bikini Girls & Sleater-Kinney. Sonic Youth also proved to have an impact on more established acts as well. When they opened for Neil Young (inducted in 1995) back in 1990, Thurston Moore encouraged Neil Young to experiment with feedback and distortion. Young's experimentation was just bordering on the commercial breakthrough of "grunge" and helped secure his legacy as the "Godfather of Grunge". Lee Renaldo & Thurston Moore was also listed as 33rd & 34th on Rolling Stone's 100 Greatest Guitarists for their experimental guitar techniques.
Continuing to establish themselves as one of the pioneering fathers of alternative rock (or in the case of Gordon, mothers) they headlined the first incarnation of Lollapalooza (1991-97) back in 1995 which lead to them appearing on 1996 The Simpson's episode "Homerpalooza" and they performed their noise rock version of the theme during the show's ending credits. Such mainstream pop culture recognition is pretty good for an underground, avant-garde noise rock band.
#1: The Monkees
Years Snubbed: 30 Years Nominated: 0
The Monkees became a huge pop culture phenomenon, which periodically has gone through countless "retro" revivals where they have been introduced to a new generation of fans. But critically they were dismissed as a second-rate The Beatles. Also, their authenticity as a real band has been questioned, due to the fact that they didn't play on their first couple of albums (they would add the vocals after the fact), they didn't write most of their own tunes, and initially, they had very little control over their own image or music (even though you could say the same thing concerning The Beatles first couple of albums, and many other bands of their time period). In many ways, they have been dismissed as simply a mass-produced product.
Later on, the band did gain respect within the music industry because of their well-published battles for creative control. Eventually, the band won those battles and they were able to play their own instruments and had creative control over the music they recorded. They also played their own instruments when they played live, and they did build a reputation for putting on an entertaining live show.
It is also good to note that they had the respect of The Beatles (inducted in 1988). John Lennon (inducted in 1994) being a fan, made the following statement to Micheal Nesmith about the band: "I think you're the greatest comic talent since the Marx Brothers. I've never missed one of your programs." George Harrison (inducted in 2004) also made the following statement concerning the band's efforts to gain creative control of their music: "It's obvious what's happening, there's talent there. They're doing a TV show, it's a difficult chore and I wouldn't be in their shoes for the world. When they get it all sorted out, they might turn out to be the best."
The Monkees also ended up being an unexpected influence on punk and alternative rock. The Sex Pistols (inducted in 2006) & Minor Threat (along with numerous other garage & punk bands) covered: "(I'm Not Your) Steppin' Stone". Paul Westerberg of The Replacements considered The Monkees to be a big influence as well. Also, Run-D.M.C. (inducted in 2009) covered The Monkees "Mary Mary".
Two of The Monkees songs: "I'm a Believer" & "Last Train To Clarksville" are included in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame as "Songs That Shaped Rock & Roll." It is about time The Monkees joined the Hall as well.
Daydream Believer - The Monkees
Questions & Answers
Question: Why isn't Doug Sahm (Sir Douglas Quintet, Texas Tornados) on your list? Also, I'd make the argument that Tampa Red had a broader influence that a wider range of performers covered son House -- particularly since he recorded more, sold more records and his songs. I definitely agree with you about Link Wray and Dick Dale.
Answer: I agree that you can make strong arguments for both Doug Sahm and Tampa Red, and they are both worthy of consideration for induction into the Hall. As far as my list goes, it is almost impossible to narrow a list like this down to 15. Even though I try hard to be objective, personal taste and personal familiarity will come into play.
© 2012 CJ Baker
LaustCawz on January 08, 2020:
Should've already mentioned I also agree about Weird Al & The Monkees, who still swait nomination, let alone induction. Btw, the past tense of lead (as in "to lead" is actually led.
Dennis HOLIDAY on October 28, 2018:
NO GRAND FUNK RAILROAD?
Nx from Australia on September 18, 2018:
More often than not, I'm ambivalent about lists like this one. A part of me buys in, with 'how dare they!' and 'it's an outrage!' when it comes to the exclusion of bands like MC5 and Kraftwerk.
I've been tempted on a couple of occasions to dig a little and find out the process by which artists are chosen, but have stopped short. Why bother trying to wrap one's head around a system that results in the inclusion of Bon Jovi and the continued omission of Motörhead?
Another, more significant part knows that it's a bit of a joke, really. The whole geared towards fame and popularity. It's not the Rock & Roll Hall of Influence, or Originality. It's reserved for the big sellers, with the occasional tip of the hat to a commercial under-performer, to give the appearance of being cool, or at least, not dinosaurs. That's why the Velvet Underground got a nod in 1996.
My favourite band is the Pixies. They're in the same position, basically, as the VU. They didn't sell a boatload of records, but they were inspirational and massively influential. It's difficult for me to look back to the mid to late 1980's, musically speaking, without bias. I despised bands like Bon Jovi, Motley Crue, Poison.
To me they were utterly empty, homogeneous, masturbatory whores, all hair and spandex. Cookie cutter melodies, tinny, jerk off guitar solos, lyrically vapid, all the poetry of an elementary schooler. Every rose has its thorn, every night has its dawn, fuck off. Oh, we're halfway there, oh oh, livin' on a prayer. These halfwits made John Cougar Mellencamp sound like William Faulkner and Bono like Yeats.
When Bon Jovi were inducted in 2018, I was reminded of the old Groucho Marx line about not wanting to be in a club that would have him as a member. When a band like that is given a place in the official pantheon of greats, it's reinforcement of the already proven fact that the vast majority of inductees are there because of record sales, not because of their contribution to the art of popular music. Bon Jovi are interchangeable with any of the hair bands of the soft middle 80's. The difference lies solely in number of units sold.
Jackie smith on February 27, 2018:
Joe cocker where is he. His performance at Woodstock. Was enough
Dennisholiday3@ Gmail.com on October 19, 2017:
They don't want Grand Funk Railroad in The Hall because they beat THE BEATLES ; blew away ZEPPELIN and scared away THE STONES. PLOP
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on January 27, 2014:
I totally agree with you Oldiemusic that there would have been no Beatles if it wasn't for Lonnie Donegan. That is a fairly significant musical legacy. I also agree about The Smiths. Thanks for the read and the comments!
oldiesmusic from United States on January 27, 2014:
After reading Lonnie Donegan's history (and watched some of his videos, I loved his live performance "Cumberland Gap", btw), he really should be inducted on the Hall of Fame. Without him, there would be no Beatles. Simple as that.
And the Smiths too... I think almost every jangle pop/twee/indie musician has acknowledged The Smiths as a very big influence.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on December 17, 2013:
Glimmer Twin Fan, I agree with you that the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame induction process is very subjective. This is part of the reason why we end up with such fun and heated debates. Thanks for the read and the comment.
Claudia Mitchell on December 17, 2013:
It's about time KISS got in. Would love it if some of your others got in too. It's such a subjective process. Of course, I'd love to see the Smiths get in and MC5, The Pixies, Motorhead and, well pretty much your whole list, but we'll see. Nice hub, gotta go get my earbuds now.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on December 17, 2013:
With the 2014 Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inductees just announced and KISS (my former #1 pick) being inducted, I updated the Hub.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on December 08, 2013:
Bat115, that is a good question. It probably didn't do anything to help the relationship between Smith and Morrissey. But I guess that is an example of the fun debates that are created by the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nomination and selection process. Thanks for the read and comment!
Tim from Los Angeles, CA on December 08, 2013:
Wonder how Morrissey felt about The Cure getting a Nomination before The Smiths? What with the feud between him and Robert Smith?
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on October 17, 2013:
withoutApause, you make a number of compelling points. Also three of your picks are nominated this year, so it will be interesting to see what happens. Thanks for the read and the comment.
withoutApause on October 14, 2013:
If people want their RRHOF "pure" with only so called "Rock & Roll Artists", then create your own hall of fame. I find that everyone in the hall has had an impact on rock and roll EVEN if they are also hip/hop, reggaee, country, soul, R&B, disco, and folk artists. Everyone in deserves to be in and I know that there are artists we all would LOVE to have in their (some that I would be delighted to see the hall include Roxy Music, Gram Parsons, The Smiths, N.W.A., Big Star, Lee Scratch Perry, Love, Chic, Eric B. and Rakim and the Zombies), but that doesn't mean we should hate the hall and the whole concept of the hall for not having them inducted. And plus if people really want only "ROCK AND ROLL", then why aren't people arguing that on the first year of the hall's creation, soul & R&B artists such as James Brown, Ray Charles, and Sam Cooke were inducted? They are all top notch artists who have had an enormous impact on rock & roll but their music isn't neccesarily considered the so called "Rock and Roll". Rock and roll has evolved through time and spread into R&B, folk, disco, reggae and rap, so that's why groups like ABBA, the Bee Gees, Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five, Jimmy Cliff, The Lovin' Spoonful, Run DMC, the Dells, Donna Summer and any other artist are in the Rock and Roll hall of fame. And every single inductee has been an inspiration on the evolution of music and deserves their spot in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on September 11, 2013:
I agree on the Madonna point. You also have artists such as Abba and then you have the whole debate concerning rap and reggae and other genres that are not really considered rock. Music is becoming so sub divided that the lines are becoming blurred. This question on what is rock is only going to become more and more complicated over the years. So those with an overly rigid definition are going to continue to have a lot to be upset about.
Donna Herron from USA on September 11, 2013:
I think the challenge began when Madonna was inducted. To my mind, she is pop. not rock in roll. With her induction, the RnR HoF has opened the doors to possibly considering acts like Britney Spears, Katie Perry (and a number of others I can't even remember their names) in future years.
With more musicians crossing musical boundaries, the HoF's job is just going to get more difficult. Neither Lucinda Williams, Ani Difranco, or Ryan Adams are completely rock and roll, but all deserve to be inducted when they are eligible.
I'm sure when they started the HoF, this all seemed relatively straight forward, but as you stated, it's very complicated and controversial. Makes for a great discussion, though :)
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on September 11, 2013:
Thanks purl3agony for the read and the comment. I agree defining rock & roll is a challenge.
I also agree with you about Jann Wenner and Rolling Stone having a lot of control. But I guess the debates and controversies are part of the fun.
Donna Herron from USA on September 11, 2013:
There's two main issues with choosing artists to be induced into the RnR Hall of Fame: 1) as you pointed out - what is the criteria? and 2) which might be more important - how to define "rock and roll". They kept Neil Diamond out for years because, supposedly, he wasn't rock and roll. Now, I might argue that he deserves to be included simply because he's a great performer and set an image type that was followed by a number of other rock and roll singers. But if people are voted in based being great stage performers, you need to start looking at Barry Manilow, Bette Midler, and a bunch of other folks that I don't really think of as rock in roll, but more as "entertainers" (not that there's anything wrong with that).
I don't think the Smiths will ever be included - didn't make a big enough splash here in the US. And Jann Wenner seems set on keeping the Monkees out. It's sad, but Jann and Rolling Stone have a lot of control over who gets inducted.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on December 29, 2012:
PDX, I agree about Sonic Youth & Weird Al. I also am not a fan of all of the bands listed and I also think that KISS is overrated. But I don't have to be a fan to acknowledge an artists considerable contribution to rock music. Thanks for the comment and the shared.
CJ Baker (author) from Parts Unknown on December 29, 2012:
Alecia, no worries about the length of your ramble. Thanks for the response and you make many interesting points. I agree that what sells is a key element, and many of the artists I have included are not entirely mainstream. My taste tend to run a bit less mainstream, and I am someone who takes an interest in the historical development of music. That being said a band like KISS does sell and they have been excluded because of politics. But I agree not everyone is going to be happy, and it is the debates that follow that are part of the fun.
Justin W Price from Juneau, Alaska on December 29, 2012:
Sonic Youth is my all time favorite band. Weird Al is a genius. Both these artists should be in the rock hall... though I thought SY was, for some reason. I view the rock n roll hall of fame much like the Grammy and the emmys... the best work doesn't get nominated, only the work that's popular with the general public. The public made Justin bieber popular... doesn't mean he deserves a grammy.
I'm not a fan of all the artists listed (Kiss is highly overrated, IMHO), but you made good cases for all of them. Well done. Shared.
Alecia Murphy from Wilmington, North Carolina on December 29, 2012:
You make a lot of sense in this post. I'm going to be honest and say that a lot of the artists you mentioned, I have never heard of. It's not that I did it purposefully it's just that I am more of the mindset of someone who likes to have the music find me than struggling to find it myself. So what I hear on the radio, television, or online is what I follow. And I'm sure I'm not alone.
However, I think a lot of the artists you mentioned came about in an era where music wasn't as easy to find as it is now. Yet I don't think that's the problem with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. I think it has more to do with them seeing what sells more than anything. They have money invested in this and I think it's harder when you have more lesser known acts in the Hall of Fame than bigger name artists. Also, if the voters are anything like the board that selects Grammy Nominees, there is also a power element involved.
While I think no one will ever be fully happy with what goes on in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, The Grammys or any other institution of the like it is interesting to see how the general public takes it. Great hub, hope I didn't ramble too long.