Who Sang It Best? "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" - Spinditty - Music
Updated date:

Who Sang It Best? "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town"

Music enthusiast FlourishAnyway introduces some fun competition into the holidays by ranking cover versions of popular Christmas songs.

Some of the best known Christmas songs have been covered by a variety of artists. We look at the classic tune, "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" and rank 14 contenders, including Mariah Carey, Jackson 5, Springsteen, and Jessie J.  Who do YOU prefer?

Some of the best known Christmas songs have been covered by a variety of artists. We look at the classic tune, "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" and rank 14 contenders, including Mariah Carey, Jackson 5, Springsteen, and Jessie J. Who do YOU prefer?

From Kiddie Song to Christmas Favorite

"Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" celebrates the child in all of us who yearns to believe in the magic of Santa. However, this perennial Christmas favorite was almost never recorded because it was considered too juvenile.

In 1934, songwriter Haven Gillespie penned the lyrics in about 15 minutes, then composer J. Fred Coots wrote the basic melody in another 10 minutes or so. The upbeat number features a narrator cautioning kids to be on their best behavior in the time leading up to Christmas. That's because Santa Claus is watching and taking notes on whether to assign them to the good list or the naughty one.

After the seasonal ditty was rejected by their music publisher, the pair offered it to Eddie Cantor, a singer and performer who hosted a top-rated radio show. He would have passed on the song, too, had it not been for his wife, Ida. Fortunately, the missus convinced Cantor to reconsider the Christmas carol as one that would genuinely appeal to all ages.

Cantor thus sang the holiday song during his Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade radio broadcast in November 1934. There was nothing juvenile about the success that followed. The song became an instant sensation, selling 30,000 records and 100,000 copies of sheet music the following day. By Christmas, nearly half a million copies of the sheet music had flown off the shelves.

In the decades since, "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" has become one of the highest-earning holiday songs of all time. Sadly, however, Coots transferred his copyright to a music publisher in 1981, several years before his death, agreeing to a lowball figure of $100,000 for the rights to the popular song. In 2016, the songwriter's family finally won back Coots' rights to the Christmas tune, now valued at nearly $3 million.

"Who Sang It Best?": Here's How It Works

With many artists singing the same Christmas tunes, the sleigh has become overloaded. Let's rank them and cross some off the list.

In the "Who Sang It Best?" series, we start with the original (or earliest charting) version of popular songs that have been covered multiple times. Then we present a set of contenders, artists who have released cover versions in any genre. Some cover versions honor the original artist's style while others are reinterpretations.

Since the original song version is typically considered "the standard," we don't include it in our overall rankings. Instead, we display it first for comparison, with up to 14 contenders presented next in ranked order. Vote on your preferences:

  • Do you prefer the original song or a cover version?
  • Which of the cover versions do you prefer?

"Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Bing Crosby and The Andrews Sisters (1947)

Bing Crosby was the most popular artist of his time—an Academy Award winning actor, a singer known for belting out his vocals, a radio host, and a television star. By the time he released this early rendition of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" and saw it make the Billboard charts, Crosby had already recorded "White Christmas" (still the best-selling single of all time). A year later, in 1948, he was voted "the most admired man alive," ahead of both Jackie Robinson and the Pope. Now that is a superstar!

As multi-talented as Bing Crosby was, let's acknowledge, however, that no one is perfect. Not every artist can blow the competition away with every song they sing. That may sound sacrilegious to true Crosby devotees, but when it comes to this song, more recent artists have sung it better.

Although I like the big band vibe here, Crosby's voice lacks strength, and it is overshadowed at points by the squeaky-high vocals of The Andrews Sisters. Although the sound of those three sisters was intended to balance him out, their vocals are so buoyant that the effect borders on ridiculous. It's as if the girls have been inhaling helium.

Crosby was a frequent collaborator with The Andrews Sisters, and they were popular in their own right, recording songs such as "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy." This version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" peaked at #22 on the Billboard chart. Listen to various artists who later covered the song and then decide: Who sang it best?

Reader Poll

1. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Mariah Carey (1994)

This rip roarin' version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" starts off deceptively mild with several bars of the melody from Brahms's Lullaby (which you might know as "Go to Sleep Little Baby"). But then put on your seatbelt because Mariah Carey quickly segues to a revved up Christmas number.

Carey is full of seasonal vim and vigor, celebrating Santa's impending arrival at full tilt. She adds the following stanza that isn't in the original version:

The kids in girl and boy land
Will have a jubilee
They're gonna build a toy land
All around the Christmas tree.

The pop diva sings to the back of the stadium, and her notes hit the rafters. Referred to as the "Songbird Supreme," Carey holds nothing back with this tune. Both the background music and the supporting chorus back her expertly rather than competing with the superstar Grammy Award-winner. This is definitely the version to beat in my book!

2. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by The Crystals (1963)

One of the defining sounds of the 1960s, The Crystals was a top-tier girl group. Their song "Da Doo Ron Ron (When He Walked Me Home)" was named by Rolling Stone magazine as one of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. By lending their distinctive style to "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town," this iconic group influenced how later pop and rock artists interpreted the holiday song. The Crystals' emphasis on "Santa" in "Santa Claus is comin' to town" is especially memorable.

This version is speedy, high spirited, and nostalgically 1960s. Admittedly, The Crystals' lengthy spoken introduction adds little and doesn't match the tempo of the remainder of the song. However, that's the only part of this version that I don't absolutely love. Note that Mariah Carey's extra stanza about the kids building a toyland around the Christmas tree is based on The Crystals' version. This is a whirlwind of a cover song that you'll want to play again and again.

3. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by The Jackson 5 (1970)

Get ready for the high voltage vocals of a youthful Michael Jackson as he gleefully hits the high notes. The adolescent singer barely contains his enthusiasm as he looks forward to Santa's visit. A British survey in 2012 named "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by The Jackson 5 as one of top 10 cringeworthy Christmas songs around. I say they must be Scrooges. (What's wrong with them?)

You'll probably notice that this cover features a stanza that many others do not—one that was borrowed from the version by Bing Crosby and The Andrew Sisters (or Johnny Mercer and The Pied Pipers, if you prefer). It adds here to the juvenile effect:

Little tin horns, and little toy drums
Rooty-toot-toot, and rump-a-tum-tums
Curly-haired dolls, that tootle and coo
Elephants, boats, and kiddie cars too.

Although the 11-year-old singer and his brothers perform as The Jackson 5, MJ is the real star, as his energetic vocals clearly outshine the rest. This rendition captures a bittersweet time in our culture that we'll never get back. It predates his phenomenal solo career, the rumors and scandals, and all of his plastic surgery. If we could only go back.

4. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Jessie J (2018)

This cover version begins in a breathy, almost sultry manner. Then it takes a hard right turn as jazz-infused music cuts in. The vibrant, creative side of the singer steps forward and gets toes tapping.

Jessie J approaches the Christmas tune with the skill and verve of the international pop star that she is, providing a light, fun treatment of the song. Rather than stick exclusively with the original lyrics, there is some improvisation with the song's bridge, but it does not detract:

Here comes old Santa Claus
Here comes Santa
He's coming and it won't be long
It won't be long
Here comes old Santa Claus
In his red suit
He's coming and it won't be long... .

5. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Bruce Springsteen & The E Street Band (1981)

Bruce Springstten has been treating concert goers to this rock version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" since 1978. He re-released his 1981 rendition of the holiday song in 2007. His voice is raspy and off-key in some places, and he scream-sings through parts and laughs through others. However, he's iconically, irreplaceably The Boss. It's a lively, albeit imperfect rendition.

6. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Frank Sinatra (1948)

Here is both ear candy and eye candy too—Ol' Blue Eyes rendering a suave, snappy version of this Christmas classic during his early years. My God, the man was something to behold. But I digress. Frank Sinatra released this cover at age 33, in the decades before his drinking and cigar smoking deepened his voice. Sinatra's version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" is quick paced, classy, and jazz, of course. It is also no nonsense and informal enough to accommodate his lyrically veering off script towards the end.

The singer's warnings about Santa's naughty list may remind you how this icon of modern music was often the subject of gossip columns for his extramarital affairs and alleged ties to organized crime. Sinatra has been called "the Greatest Voice of the 20th Century." He won an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor in From Here to Eternity and was an 11-time Grammy winner.

7. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Michael Bublé (2011)

This snazzy, jazzy, retro version is the top-downloaded cover of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" on Spotify. No offense to Michael Bublé, but I don't understand that. While the Canadian crooner offers crisp, cheeky vocals and a sophisticated vibe, his efforts impress me as overly restrained. While he seems like he's trying too hard to be clever with the phrase, "big bad man with the long white beard," that's actually lifted from the version by Bing Crosby and The Andrews Sisters. (It didn't work for Bing either.)

Moreover, there are several points where the sudden, blaring brass instruments startle the hell out of me. Overall, there are a number of worse versions of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" but also significantly better ones.

8. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Michael Bolton (2006)

Michael Bolton belts out this Santa tune, gives it some gusto, then leans into the lyrics in this swingin' jazz number. It's a strong, melodramatic performance by the Grammy Award winner and he'll have you swaying to the music. Why not use this version to wake up a slow Christmas party? It's got the right balance of sex appeal and playfulness.

9. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Lonestar (2000)

If you enjoy country music, you probably remember this band for their string of number one singles from the late 1990s and early 2000s, including "No News," "Amazed" and "I'm Already There." Lonestar is still together, although we haven't heard much from them since then.

If Santa was a cowboy, this is the version he'd be blasting out of the windows of his pickup truck. However, it wouldn't be my choice, no matter how much nostalgia I have for the group. Lonestar's country version is very twangy, the introduction drags on unnecessarily, and this ostensibly Christmas tune sounds like every other Lonestar song recorded. Only the most dedicated of their fans would crank up this boot scootin' number up as they down the egg nog and try to stay on the jolly ol' elf's good list.

10. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Justin Bieber (2011)

Someone needed to clue the Beebster in that this was supposed to be a holiday tune. Unfortunately, industrial sounds start this cover version off, then they're followed up with filler words such as "yeah," "hey," and "shake it, shake it." How ridiculous. Tween audiences might not mind that Justin Bieber speak-sings in places and poorly modifies his emphasis on the words, but the tune holds little appeal for adults. The song video appeared at the end of the 2011 Christmas film, Arthur Christmas.

11. Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Pentatonix (2014)

There are songs that a capella group Pentatonix nails, but this isn't one of them. The Grammy Award-winning group vocally underperform and suffer from the absence of a clear lead vocalist here. They also insert beatboxing and a repetitive loop of "Santa is coming to town" as empty fillers into this song in lieu of instruments. The effect here is annoying.

If you want to hear a truly superlative holiday offering by Pentatonix, try "Mary Did You Know?" or "Hallelujah." The group rose to fame after winning the third season of NBC's The Sing-Off.

12. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Human Nature (2013)

It's kinda hard to call this Australian group a "boy band" since they've been around for 30 years, flying mostly under radar of international fame. By now, these boys are middle aged.

Human Nature offers this okay-sounding pop/doo wop version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town." It is a pleasant enough seasonal cover, although plagued with its share of off-key moments and harmony that sometimes misses the mark. And the part in middle where they stop singing and just talk their way through it? Not a fan. This Human Nature version is not quite ready for prime time.

13. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by Andrea Bocelli (2009)

What a trainwreck! Mix the slow, operatic-like, overenunciated lyrics of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town," add Andrea Bocelli's Italian accent and a sassy kid chorus that is equally out of place, and you have this mess. In addition, there are places where Bocelli seems like he's just looking for an excuse to hit a high note (e.g., "good for goodness sake" and " you better watch out"). I guess this is like a peanut butter and mayonnaise sandwich—there's probably someone who likes it, but certainly not me. Bocelli should stick to more classical musical selections..

14. "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" by The Carpenters (1984)

Although the buttery quality of Karen Carpenter's buttery is as impeccable as ever, this song is a complete misfit for her. There are worse aspects to this version of "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town" than the lackluster chorus or the odd way the songstress emphasizes all the wrong words.

Most disastrously, it features a 1970s ambiance of intimacy and romance with a laggardly tempo and sexy saxophone solo. Eww. Applying the standard "Carpenters formula" to this Christmas ditty is straight-out weird. This easy listening cover neither generates excitement about Santa's upcoming visit nor playfully threatens the ill-behaved to tighten up to avoid the naughty list. Instead, what it offers is low-key creepiness.

Karen Carpenter died in 1983 as a consequence of her years-long battle with anorexia, and this was a posthumously released song. Her brother, Richard, took material that they had decided not to use for a 1978 Christmas album and recorded around it. Some people have criticized him as exploiting his sister after her death.

Reader Poll: Your Favorite Cover Version

© 2019 FlourishAnyway

Comments

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on February 28, 2020:

Peggy - Happy you enjoyed ol' Santa in February. He's probably napping pretty hard by now.

Peggy Woods from Houston, Texas on February 28, 2020:

This time I could not just pick one. In no particular order, I enjoyed these the most: Andrea Bocelli, Michael Bublé, Mariah Carey, Frank Sinatra, and The Carpenters. Great selection!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 29, 2019:

Cynthia - You have a good point there! I can't believe people would vote that the most annoying holiday song. Have a wonderful week!

Cynthia Zirkwitz from Vancouver Island, Canada on September 29, 2019:

I most like the Jackson 5 version for its energy and the thought of Michael jumping around and singing it with all he had to give! Pretty amazing that a boy not too far from a strict religion that didn't recognize birthday celebrations or Christmas could bring so much passion to a song about Santa Claus! Just sayin'

Because of this series I am getting so geared up for Christmas-- want to share this with my granddaughters but I know that they are more excited by their October birthdays and Hallowe'en right now, so I will late a little. This was a good idea!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 20, 2019:

Nithya - Thank you for reporting out your favorite. I hope you are doing well.

Nithya Venkat from Dubai on September 19, 2019:

A great selection, my favorite is Michael Buble. The sound of his voice is divine!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 19, 2019:

Dora - I hope you get a chance to listen to at least a few of them. It may be a bit early in the season to focus on Christmas, but I sure loved listening to them and am already looking forward to December.

Dora Weithers from The Caribbean on September 19, 2019:

Now, I would like to hear all these artists, and I"ll have to make time for that. Thanks for putting this list together.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 17, 2019:

Lora - I'm glad you enjoyed this. I've been playing Christmas music in September as I researched this article and have had my husband eye-rolling (and at times cringing). He especially disliked that Carpenters version as did I. By the time Christmas rolls around we should be totally in the holiday spirit. Thank you for reading and listening along.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 17, 2019:

Linda - Wasn't that one surprisingly impressive? I never would have been aware of her version had I not researched it for this article. Thanks for sharing your favorite!

Lora Hollings on September 16, 2019:

This was a great way to spend the last 20 minutes, Flourish! Deciding which contender sang it best. I agree with you about Bing Crosby and the Andrew sisters. It just didn't make it for me and many others too! My favorite version is the one sang by Frank Sinatra who when it comes to pop tunes or torch songs just can't be beat. His voice, his musical interpretation is just the best! A fun and well written article. This is a must read and listen to article before the Christmas season! Thanks for sharing.

Linda Crampton from British Columbia, Canada on September 16, 2019:

The Jessie J version was my favorite. As always, it was enjoyable to listen to the different versions of the song and to read about them.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 16, 2019:

Heidi - I don’t know what Bocelli was thinking! So strange! I’m glad you enjoy this series. Some of the songs have 100-200 cover versions, thus it can be challenging to determine which versions to profile. Thanks for sharing your favorite.

Heidi Thorne from Chicago Area on September 16, 2019:

I'm going to go with Fred Astaire in the Rankin Bass stop motion Christmas special, Santa Claus is Comin' to Town. But one of the versions I remember most is the Jackson 5.

I gotta say, though, that when some high brow signer (Andrea Bocelli) sings catchy kitschy songs, it's just weird for me.

Let's see... how many more Christmas "who sang it best" entries are left? These are totally fun. Thanks for the memories and the playlists!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 16, 2019:

Liz - I've been planning ahead for a while now. I figured if I waited until it was Christmas season to write these, then it would be too late. Thanks for reading along.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 16, 2019:

Bill - I couldn't believe that survey in Britain voting Jackson 5's version of this song one of the most irritating Christmas songs. I've listened to a lot of Christmas music in my research and actually like it.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on September 16, 2019:

Pamela - Some are seriously overrated while others just don’t get heard. I can’t imagine someone beating Mariah’s version but would love to hear it when someone comes close. Thanks for stopping by.

Liz Westwood from UK on September 16, 2019:

I had no idea there were so many cover versions of this popular Christmas song. You are planning ahead and getting in the seasonal spirit in very good time this year.

Bill Holland from Olympia, WA on September 16, 2019:

I rarely vote against Bing, but in this case I go with the Jackson 5. I've always loved their upbeat tempo and joyous rendition of this song.

Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on September 16, 2019:

I must agree with you about Mariah's version probably being the best. Some of these artists thhat I like did butcher the song in my opinion.